Skip to main content
Health and Aging
A-Z Health Topics Index
News of Note
Research and Funding
Blog - Inside NIA
Division of Extramural Activities
Division of Aging Biology
Division of Behavioral and Social Research
Division of Geriatrics and Clinical Gerontology
Division of Neuroscience
Intramural Research Program
Office of Special Populations
Scientific Review Branch
Training & Career Development
Budget & Testimony
Careers at NIA
National Advisory Council on Aging (NACA)
Offices & Divisions
You are here
Inside NIA: A Blog for Researchers
How to avoid annoying your reviewers—tips from review, part 1
Dr. Ferrell, this is a helpful insight. Thank you.
What is your opinion about the reviewers who do a poor job of reviewing and/or not really qualified to review. If a reviewer is not working on a specific field (e.g. treatment of heart failure) how can he/she comment the novely and 'innovative-ness' of the proposed goals /deliverables of the application/
Of course we do our very best to find the most appropriate reviewers for each application. Given the review load and composition of a given review panel, the three assigned reviewers on an application may have expertise ranging from specific to more general, and the critiques will vary in specificity accordingly. We do ask all assigned reviewers to comment on each criterion based on their reading of the application and on discussion with the review panel (if the application is discussed).
Very insightful and helpful. Thank you!
One of my pet peeves as a reviewer, apart from truly substantive matters, is applications that underline what the writer wants to emphasize as important. I find the underlining to distract from the content, and ultimately to be distinctively less effective than clearly written prose without the underlining.
I'd like to see the distribution of undergraduate institution attended for investigators awarded and not awarded grants. Is that info available?
We just love the post and the audio verification. Anyways how many good applications do you think just get overlooked!
Get new posts by email.
About this Blog
NIA Funding Opportunities
Spotlight on Aging Research
NIA Main Website
NIH Director's Blog
NCCIH Research Blog
I Am Intramural
Making community connections is key for recruitment
Access international data from HRS “family of studies”
Balance in grant peer review: recruiting reviewers from diverse backgrounds
Career Development Awards
Small Business Funding
Connect with NIH
Get Acrobat (PDF) Reader
National Institute on Aging
31 Center Drive, MSC 2292, Bethesda, MD 20892
National Institutes of Health
U.S. Department of Health & Human Services